*Book 9 of the Matthew Scudder series*
"Sometimes it's a dog-eat-dog world and the rest of the time it's the other way around."
This year I've realized that I'm not that big of a fan of standard
detective series. They get too repetitive and frankly boring after a
while. It nearly broke my heart when I realized that I was starting to
feel the same way about this book in Lawrence Block's Scudder series,
arguably the top of the detective pack. As I read, I started to notice
the formula and the trends. Once again, Scudder has to explain that he's
not an official private detective, once again Scudder "struggles" with what
to charge people for his services, even though he always seems to settle
on the same price (somewhere between $2-3K), and once again Scudder has a
moment where he's unsatisfied with his work and considers giving the
client a refund, even though he's never actually gone through with it
yet. I guess it's designed for the casual reader that might jump into
the series at anytime, but for me it becomes a slog reading the same shit over and over. At least in this
book we were spared him having to explain why he's not a cop anymore;
I'm a little tired of hearing that story too.
This time
around Scudder takes on two cases that somehow end up connected,
determining whether or not a TV producer was responsible for the rape
and murder of his wife, as well as tracking down the masked sex killers
in a grisly smut film he stumbles onto in the middle of watching a VHS
rental of The Dirty Dozen. This novel's plot developments
were based on so many coincidences that the plotting seemed a bit lazy
this time around. But even with these issues that I personally had and the fact
that this book lacks the emotional weight of Eight Million Ways to Die, the freshness of When The Sacred Ginmill Closes,
or the urgent danger of A Ticket to the Boneyard, it's still as
thoughtful, readable, and well-written as any of the other novels in
Block's Scudder series, with some cool characters and nasty villains.
"We are closer than close, you and I. We are brothers in blood and semen."
So although it suffers from the usual stale
repetitiveness as other later novels in most mystery series, it's still a
Block novel so it's still one of the better detective books out there. If you're going to read a repetitive detective series, this should be the one you read.
"Well it's a hell of a story," he said. "And I guess you could say it has a happy ending, because you didn't drink and you aren't going to jail."
GRADE: B-